📞 Morrisville 315-684-3171  ·  Hamilton 315-825-9800  ·  Canastota 315-875-7000
Our Story

Part of life in Madison County since 1923

For over 100 years, families across Madison County have trusted Dougherty Pharmacy. We’re not a chain — we’re your neighbors, and we’ve been here longer than just about anyone.

Locally owned since 1923

It started on Main Street in Morrisville

In 1923, a few years after graduating from the University at Buffalo’s pharmacy school, Lester Dougherty returned home and bought the business at 14 East Main Street from retiring pharmacist J.P. Wetmore — opening Dougherty’s Drug Store.

In those early days, Lester and his family lived right upstairs, and the Doughertys cared for their neighbors on Main Street for decades — first Lester, then his wife Hazel, then their sons George and John. The pharmacy has passed to new owners in the generations since, but the name and the hometown spirit behind it have never left. Today that tradition continues under owner Colin Valenta — now from three locations across Madison County.

Dougherty's Drug Store in Morrisville, NY, around 1923
Through the years

A century of caring for our community

1923

Lester Dougherty buys retiring pharmacist J.P. Wetmore’s store at 14 East Main and opens Dougherty’s Drug Store in Morrisville.

1951

After Lester’s passing, his wife Hazel keeps the pharmacy serving the community while raising their nine children.

1962

Sons George and John Dougherty become co-owners and remodel the store. John was a graduate of Albany College of Pharmacy; George went on to serve as Morrisville Fire Chief.

1995

Jennifer Caloia and her husband Chris Klein take ownership, carrying the Dougherty name forward.

1996

A fire destroys the store — and the community rallies as it’s rebuilt on the very same Main Street spot.

2015

Colin Valenta becomes owner, continuing the independent, hometown tradition that started nearly a century earlier.

2017

Dougherty Pharmacy opens a second location in Hamilton.

2023

Dougherty Pharmacy celebrates 100 years of serving the families of Madison County.

2024

A third location opens in Canastota — bringing the same trusted care to even more neighbors.

100 years in pictures

Our story, page by page

A look back through the decades — compiled with the help of the Dougherty family and the Morrisville College Library.

What we stand for

The Dougherty difference

🤝

Personal Care

Real conversations with pharmacists who know you by name and have time to help.

🏘️

Locally Owned

Decisions made right here in our community, by people who live here too.

❤️

Community First

Proud to support the schools, teams, and families that make our towns home.

Come see what hometown care feels like

Stop by any of our three locations, or refill online today.